Top 25 Ice Cream in Tampa, FL

Ranked by Google rating and review volume. Updated 2026-08-11.

1. 1
   Ice Screamin/Tampa

   ★ 4.91,477 reviews
2. 2
   Sea Maids Creamery (Icecream & a Little More)

   ★ 4.9879 reviews
3. 3
   CALI's BODEGA BUS - Convenience Store, Deli. ONE STOP SHOP

   ★ 4.9493 reviews
4. 4
   Retro House Coffee Bar & Asian Bistro

   ★ 4.9387 reviews
5. 5
   Cream de la Cream

   ★ 4.9359 reviews
6. 6
   Yogurt Naturally

   ★ 4.9259 reviews
7. 7
   Bo's Ice Cream

   ★ 4.83,451 reviews
8. 8
   Ben & Jerry’s

   ★ 4.81,023 reviews
9. 9
   Strachan's Ice Cream & Desserts - South Tampa

   ★ 4.9156 reviews
10. 10
    Toffee to Go & More

    ★ 4.8394 reviews
11. 11
    BRICK AND BAY MINI MART

    ★ 4.9135 reviews
12. 12
    D'Lites Ice Cream - Carrollwood

    ★ 4.8308 reviews
13. 13
    Chill Bros Scoop Shop

    ★ 4.8280 reviews
14. 14
    Heights Public Market

    ★ 4.72,988 reviews
15. 15
    Hampton Chocolate Factory

    ★ 4.72,311 reviews
16. 16
    Dairy Joy- Tampa Ice Cream

    ★ 4.71,382 reviews
17. 17
    Crème Bakery (Preorder-only Bakery)

    ★ 4.969 reviews
18. 18
    Chill Bros Scoop Shop

    ★ 4.7653 reviews
19. 19
    Bright Ice Scoop Shop Water St

    ★ 4.7390 reviews
20. 20
    Whatever Pops

    ★ 4.7327 reviews
21. 21
    The Hyppo Hyde Park

    ★ 4.7302 reviews
22. 22
    Mayday Ice Cream Centro Ybor

    ★ 4.7285 reviews
23. 23
    Gelato-Go Tampa

    ★ 4.7279 reviews
24. 24
    Bake'n Babes To Go

    ★ 4.7257 reviews
25. 25
    Chill Bros Scoop Shop

    ★ 4.7127 reviews

Rankings use a Bayesian weighted score, not raw star averages. How we rank →